Not all tenants are created equal, and the wrong one can cost you more than just late rent. A responsible tenant translates to steady income, fewer headaches, and a better long-term return. On the flip side, the wrong tenant can lead to late payments, property damage, and costly eviction proceedings.
If you're working with a reliable real estate agent or property manager, they can help you screen applicants thoroughly and spot potential issues early. But if you're managing the process yourself, it’s important to know what to look for and what to avoid.
Here are some key red flags to keep in mind before signing that lease and turning over your property.
1. Incomplete Applications
If a tenant leaves significant portions of the rental application blank, or avoids providing references or employment info, that’s a sign to proceed with caution. A quality tenant will be upfront and thorough with their information. If they’re vague or evasive from the start, it could lead to communication issues or worse down the line.
2. Frequent Moves Without Good Reason
Everyone has life changes—new jobs, growing families, relocations, etc. But, a history of moving every 6–12 months can be a serious red flag. It may signal instability, a tendency to break leases, or an inability to get along with landlords or neighbors. Look for patterns and ask follow-up questions to better understand the “why” behind a history of frequent moves.
3. Unverifiable or Unstable Income
A tenant doesn’t need to have a six-figure salary to be a great renter, but they do need reliable, verifiable income. If the applicant can’t provide recent pay stubs, bank statements, or proof of employment, that’s worth digging into further. A common rule of thumb is that rent should not exceed 30% of their monthly income. However, in certain high-cost markets, it’s not uncommon for renters to spend well above that threshold due to rising rent prices so it’s important to assess the full financial picture rather than relying on a single metric.
4. Credit History and Transparency Count
Running a background and credit check is a non-negotiable part of tenant screening. It gives you a clearer picture of an applicant’s financial responsibility and rental history. One past eviction isn’t always a deal-breaker, but repeated late payments, collection accounts, or rental-related judgments should raise a red flag. Past behavior is often the best predictor of future reliability.
Equally as concerning? A tenant who’s unwilling to consent to screening at all. Responsible renters understand that credit and background checks are standard practice and typically won’t hesitate to comply. If someone resists or tries to avoid this step, it may signal there’s something they don’t want you to see.
5. Poor Communication During the Application Process
Let the application process be your first real glimpse into how a potential tenant handles responsibility and what it's like to work with them. If an applicant is unresponsive, dismissive, or consistently missing appointments or deadlines during this early phase, don’t assume that behavior will improve after move-in; it could be a sign of things to come.
On the other hand, a tenant who responds promptly, follows through on requests, and communicates respectfully demonstrates reliability from the start. Clear, consistent communication may not seem like a big deal during the application process, but in a landlord-tenant relationship, it’s vital. It sets the tone for a smoother rental experience on both sides.
6. Gut Feeling: Trust It (But Don’t Rely on It Alone)
You should never base your decision solely on a “gut feeling,” but if something doesn’t sit right with you, even when everything on paper checks out, it’s worth taking a step back. Combine instinct with process. Recheck their references, verify income, and don’t rush to fill a vacancy just to get rent rolling in. Taking the time to cover your bases is worth a few extra days of vacancy and may even prevent a costly or stressful situation down the line.
Final Thoughts
Tenant screening is not a foolproof process. You can’t predict everything, but by learning what red flags to watch for and building a consistent process, you’ll better protect your investment, your time, and your bottom line. Many investors will opt to hire a professional property management or leasing firm. While this comes at a cost (typically around 5% of your property's gross monthly rent), it can provide peace of mind by adding a layer of professional screening, documentation, and communication between you and your tenants. A good management company acts as both a buffer and a partner, helping you avoid common pitfalls and freeing up your time to focus on growing your portfolio.
Remember, one great tenant can turn a rental into a reliable asset, but one bad tenant can turn it into a major burden. Take the time to get it right.
Looking to finance your next fix and flip or rental property?
Let's talk about how we can support your journey.